Back
Politics

Gorton and Denton By-Election Scheduled After Labour Committee Blocks Andy Burnham's Candidacy

Generated on: Last updated: 6 sources
View source

Gorton and Denton By-Election: Starmer Blocks Burnham's Candidacy Amidst Labour Divisions

The by-election for the Gorton and Denton constituency is anticipated in late February, following the formal resignation of Labour MP Andrew Gwynne. Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham's application to stand as the Labour candidate was blocked by a Labour Party committee, a decision in which Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer participated by voting against it.

By-Election Triggered

The Gorton and Denton parliamentary seat became vacant following the resignation of former Labour minister Andrew Gwynne from the House of Commons, citing health reasons. The constituency has been continuously represented by Labour for over 90 years, and the party held a 13,000 majority in the 2024 general election.

The Gorton and Denton parliamentary seat became vacant following the resignation of former Labour minister Andrew Gwynne from the House of Commons, citing health reasons.

Andy Burnham's Candidacy Attempt

Greater Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham formally applied to Labour's National Executive Committee (NEC) to stand in the by-election by the Saturday afternoon deadline. As a directly-elected mayor, Labour rules mandate that he obtain NEC permission to seek nomination as a Labour Parliamentary candidate.

In his application letter to the NEC, Mr. Burnham stated his intention to support the Labour government and advocate for Greater Manchester at a national level. He expressed a belief that "Manchester requires national-level changes" and a need to "return to Parliament to advocate for the city," citing a perceived "direct threat" to "everything Greater Manchester has always been about."

Internal Labour Debate and Opposition

Mr. Burnham's potential candidacy generated discussion and division among Labour MPs and the NEC. Supporters, including Deputy Labour leader Angela Rayner, London Mayor Sadiq Khan, Deputy Labour leader Lucy Powell, and Energy Secretary Ed Miliband, indicated their support, highlighting his experience and potential asset to the party in Parliament. Some also expressed concerns that blocking his candidacy could undermine the will of local party members.

Conversely, some Labour MPs and allies of Sir Keir Starmer on the NEC expressed opposition. Concerns raised included:

  • The estimated financial cost of approximately £4.7 million for a new mayoral election if Mr. Burnham were to win the parliamentary seat and resign as mayor.
  • The political risk of triggering a mayoral election.
  • The NEC's potential insistence on an all-women shortlist for the by-election.
  • A perception that Mr. Burnham's return to Parliament could be an implied challenge to Sir Keir Starmer's leadership, potentially destabilizing a Labour government.

Ministerial sources described Mr. Burnham as self-focused, citing previous instances where he suggested he could mount a challenge to Sir Keir Starmer's leadership. Jo White MP expressed concerns about a "London stitch up," while Graham Stringer MP described the move as "very high-risk."

NEC Decision and Sir Keir Starmer's Involvement

On Sunday morning, a Labour Party committee blocked Mr. Burnham's bid to run as an MP. Sir Keir Starmer participated remotely in the meeting and cast a vote against allowing Mr. Burnham to stand.

A senior party figure stated that a lack of conviction regarding Mr. Burnham operating as a "team player" and a desire to avoid internal "psychodrama" influenced the decision, adding that the party should not permit "insecurity and destabilisation to indulge one man's personal ambition."

Reactions to the Decision

The decision drew varied reactions. Some interpreted it as an exercise of power by No 10. Critics within the party argued that blocking a prominent figure like Mr. Burnham was counterproductive and an an attempt to stifle democracy, with one senior Labour MP stating that "Keir is running scared and it's a very bad look."

Supporters of the leadership stated their focus was on governance and avoiding political "soap opera." The response to Mr. Burnham's exclusion was not as significant as some of Sir Keir's supporters had anticipated.

By-Election Timetable Set

The by-election is anticipated to take place in late February, with Thursday, February 26, cited as the likely date. The process began on Monday when government chief whip Jonathan Reynolds requested the writ in Parliament. By-elections must occur between 21 and 27 working days from the writ's issuance.

Labour leader Sir Keir Starmer opted for the fastest possible timetable.

This accelerated timetable is reportedly intended to limit the time other parties, specifically Reform UK and the Green Party, have to establish campaign operations within the constituency.

Electoral Landscape and Leadership Implications

Despite its historical status as a safe Labour seat, the Gorton and Denton constituency is now viewed as potentially vulnerable given Labour's recent decline in popularity. The by-election is perceived by multiple parties as a potentially close three-way contest involving Labour, Reform UK, and the Green Party. In the last general election in the constituency, Reform UK placed second and the Green Party third. Reform UK previously secured victory in the Runcorn and Helsby by-election, narrowly defeating Labour. Following Mr. Burnham's announcement, Reform UK's Lee Anderson was observed campaigning in the constituency.

A Labour victory, regardless of the margin, would be considered a positive outcome for Sir Keir Starmer, indicating the party's capacity to defeat Reform UK and the Greens without Mr. Burnham as a candidate. Conversely, a Labour defeat, particularly to Reform UK or the Green Party, could lead to increased speculation regarding Sir Keir's leadership, especially given his close association with the decision concerning Mr. Burnham's candidacy.

Such a defeat in a historically secure seat would escalate the political stakes for Sir Keir ahead of the upcoming May elections, which include contests for the Scottish and Welsh parliaments and some English councils.

There is an expectation among some Labour MPs that unfavorable results in these May elections could prompt attempts to initiate a leadership challenge.

Besides Mr. Burnham, Angela Rayner and Health Secretary Wes Streeting have also been mentioned as potential challengers to Sir Keir Starmer's leadership.