Back
Sports

Victoria Defeats Western Australia in Revived AFL Origin Match Amidst Calls for Annual Event and Club Injury Concerns

Generated on: Last updated: 11 sources
View source

AAMI AFL Origin Returns: Victoria Triumphs in Historic Clash, But Injuries Spark Debate

The AAMI AFL Origin match made its highly anticipated return on February 14, 2026, marking the first official state game in 27 years. Victoria secured a 24-point victory over Western Australia at a sold-out Optus Stadium in Perth. The event, which drew an attendance of 58,141, saw extensive preparations by both teams. However, it concluded with several players sustaining injuries, prompting a debate among clubs and coaches regarding the fixture's timing and future.

A Historic Return After 27 Years

The match was held on Saturday, February 14, 2026, at Optus Stadium in Perth, commencing at 4:40 PM AWST (7:40 PM AEDT). It was broadcast live across the Seven Network, 7plus, Foxtel, Kayo, and Fox Footy.

This event marked the return of an official AFL Origin match after 27 years, with the last competitive state-based fixture taking place in May 1999. Historically, the series experienced a decline in interest during the 1990s as the AFL transitioned into a national competition, leading to player availability challenges.

The return of Origin was confirmed by AFL Chief Executive Andrew Dillon in September 2025, citing strong demand from both fans and players and the success of the 2025 Indigenous All-Stars clash.

The perpetual trophy contested between Victoria and Western Australia is the Graham ‘Polly’ Farmer Cup.

Leadership and Star-Studded Line-ups

Patrick Cripps, captain of Carlton, led Western Australia, with Dean Cox, former West Coast player and current Sydney Swans coach, at the helm. For Victoria, Marcus Bontempelli, Western Bulldogs skipper, captained the side, coached by two-time Geelong premiership coach Chris Scott.

Western Australia's squad featured a formidable lineup including Chad Warner, Aaron Naughton, Liam Baker, Kysaiah Pickett, Luke Jackson, Shai Bolton, Jaeger O’Meara, Stephen Coniglio, Callum Ah Chee, Jordan Clark, Rory Lobb, Bradley Hill, Darcy Cameron, Samuel Taylor, Lawson Humphries, Mitchell Georgiades, Jesse Hogan, Charlie Cameron, Trent Rivers, Wil Powell, Nathan Broad, Tom Barrass, Tim English, and Jake Waterman. Pre-match, Brandon Starcevich was unavailable due to a partial ACL tear, while Jordan Clark participated despite an earlier ankle scare.

Victoria's squad boasted talents such as Nick Daicos, Sam Darcy, Max Gawn, Toby Greene, Matt Rowell, Bailey Smith, Tristan Xerri, Sam Collins, Jack Gunston, Jack Sinclair, Caleb Serong, Hugh McCluggage, Zach Merrett, Zak Butters, Lachie Ash, Blake Hardwick, Max Holmes, Noah Anderson, Ed Richards, Jacob Weitering, Joshua Battle, Ben King, Patrick Dangerfield, and Tom Stewart. Jeremy Cameron was ruled out with a broken arm and replaced by Ben King, while Toby Greene, recovering from a pre-season hip/glute injury, secured a starting position.

All 18 AFL clubs were represented in the match, with the Western Bulldogs having the most representatives (6), followed by Fremantle, Geelong, Gold Coast, and the Giants (5 each).

Intense Preparations and Player Vows

Teams arrived in Perth on Wednesday, February 12, accompanied by families, for an introductory meeting. Thursday included training at West Coast's Mineral Resources Park, with coaches engaging players in drills and strategy. Community visits were also arranged, including Zach Merrett and Marcus Bontempelli's Q&A at the Kent Street Clontarf Academy, followed by an official welcome dinner where guernseys were presented.

Captains Cripps and Bontempelli both expressed their pride. Bontempelli noted recurring questions about the game's anticipated intensity, while Cripps stated that leading Western Australia was significant for him, expressing eagerness to lead the team at Optus Stadium. Bontempelli remarked on the honor of captaining Victoria, acknowledging the "deep history and pride" associated with representing the state.

On Friday, players engaged in leisure activities before a tactical team meeting. Game day preparations were described as relaxed. Victorian defender Jacob Weitering predicted an intense start to the game, stating that playing with less than full intensity could increase injury risk. WA defender Nathan Broad emphasized the players' commitment, stating that they would approach the game with full intensity, rejecting the idea of "bruise-free football." WA ruck Darcy Cameron issued a warning to Victorian opponent Nick Daicos regarding centre bounce tactics.

Victoria Claims Victory in High-Stakes Clash

Victoria defeated Western Australia with a final score of 18.17 (125) to 15.11 (101).

Western Australia narrowed Victoria's lead to six points in the final quarter with three goals from Jesse Hogan, but Victoria ultimately secured the win.

Jesse Hogan was awarded the Graham Moss Medal as Western Australia's best player for his five goals. The EJ Whitten Medal for Victoria's best on ground player was also presented.

A Costly Victory: Post-Match Injury Toll

The high-intensity match resulted in several injuries affecting player availability for the upcoming AFL season:

  • Jacob Weitering (Carlton): Sustained a rib fracture and was assessed for potential neck and shoulder injuries.
  • Sam Taylor (GWS): Diagnosed with a high-grade hamstring strain, projected to sideline him until at least Round 5. GWS reportedly sought compensation for lost earnings.
  • Matt Rowell (Gold Coast): Suffered a shattered broken finger, requiring a cast.
  • Callum Ah Chee (Adelaide): Experienced a low-grade hamstring strain. He, along with Mitch Georgiades (Port Adelaide) and Sam Taylor, were removed from the game as a precaution due to hamstring tightness.
  • Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): Sustained a minor calf complaint, causing him to miss a pre-season match but expected back for Round 1.
  • Bailey Smith (Western Bulldogs) and Sam Darcy (Western Bulldogs): Both reported soreness post-match but recovered to play in the opening weekend.

The Future of Origin: Annual Fixture vs. Club Concerns

Following the match, both Western Australia coach Dean Cox and Victoria coach Chris Scott advocated for the State of Origin concept to be held annually. Cox suggested Perth had demonstrated its suitability as a potential annual host, citing public and government support. Scott stated there was "no apparent reason" why the event should not occur every year, suggesting the pre-season as a suitable timeframe. Jesse Hogan also expressed player enthusiasm for an annual fixture, stating there was "absolutely no reason why the players wouldn't want to buy into this every single year."

However, AFL clubs expressed concerns regarding the timing of the mid-February match and its high intensity, which saw some players record unprecedented GPS data.

Jon Ralph of Fox Footy reported frustration among clubs over the impact on their star players ahead of the Premiership season. Gold Coast CEO Mark Evans stated that while clubs value player involvement, the timing and game load require careful consideration to ensure continued support. Three-time premiership coach Damien Hardwick supported the Origin concept but criticized the timing, stating it did not suit team preparations for the season, as players were not ready for such a high-intensity game three to four weeks before Round 0. Essendon coach Brad Scott acknowledged the ongoing debate regarding optimal timing and expressed hope a suitable place for the event could be found in the schedule. Clubs indicated a potential reluctance to release players for future Origin matches, with some suggesting they might use various reasons to limit player participation if game time is not reduced.