Immigration Enforcement Elevates Labor Challenges and Costs in U.S. Construction Industry

Source Article
Generated on:

Immigration Enforcement Affects U.S. Construction Industry Labor

Overview
The U.S. construction industry is experiencing amplified labor shortages and increased operational costs, a situation attributed by industry officials to heightened immigration enforcement actions. These actions include checkpoints, raids, and detentions by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) agents, contributing to apprehension among workers.

Industry-Wide Labor Shortage
The construction sector has faced a persistent labor shortage for decades, with an average of one in three workers being foreign-born. This shortage predates recent immigration enforcement, as noted by industry leaders who cite a long-running emphasis on four-year college degrees over skilled trades training as a contributing factor. Historically, immigrant labor, including undocumented workers, has been a significant component of the construction workforce, particularly after the Great Recession when many U.S.-born workers exited the industry.

Impact of Immigration Enforcement
Recent immigration enforcement actions have been reported to exacerbate these labor challenges. Instances include:

  • ICE checkpoints observed on major roadways, specifically targeting construction vehicles.
  • Raids near construction supply stores in areas such as Los Angeles and job sites in Tallahassee, Florida, and St. Paul, Minnesota, resulting in arrests.
  • Reports from contractors of workers, including those with legal work permits, being stopped and detained for hours, leading to project delays.

A survey conducted by the Associated General Contractors of America (AGC) indicated that 92% of construction firms struggle to fill positions. Within the past six months of the survey, 28% of firms reported being affected by immigration actions:

  • 5% stated ICE agents had visited a job site.
  • 10% reported losing workers due to actual or rumored ICE raids.
  • 20% indicated concerns over immigration actions caused subcontractors to lose staff.

Ken Simonson, chief economist at AGC, stated that worker absenteeism or departure during tasks is disruptive, slowing project completion and increasing costs for both owners and contractors. The National Association of Home Builders (NAHB) estimates the ongoing worker shortage in home-building costs $11 billion annually, contributing to a deficit of approximately 1.5 million housing units in the U.S. housing market.

Government Stance and Debates
The White House and the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) have affirmed their commitment to enforcing immigration laws and prioritizing job creation for American workers. A DHS statement indicated that