Fan theories have emerged suggesting that the epilogue of Stranger Things season five may not represent a definitive conclusion to the series. One prominent theory, known as 'Conformity Gate,' proposes that the epilogue depicts an illusion created by the antagonist, Vecna, implying his defeat is not final.
Alleged Visual and Narrative Inconsistencies
Proponents of the 'Conformity Gate' theory cite various visual and narrative elements within the final episodes as evidence.
- Graduation Scene: The Hawkins High graduation scene is frequently referenced, with observers noting the characters' uniform poses. These poses have been compared to the rigid physicality previously associated with Henry Creel. Additionally, the similar cropped hairstyles of the Wheeler family members in this scene are highlighted as a point of comparison.
- Epilogue Details: Specific details from the epilogue are also cited. These include a student holding a blank yellow poster and the recurring appearance of a 'WHATZIT?' board game. The latter has been interpreted by some fans as a reference to Henry Creel's childhood nickname, 'Mr Whatsit.' Furthermore, the spines of a final stack of Dungeons & Dragons books are scrutinized, with some interpretations suggesting they spell 'X A LIE,' potentially referencing 'Dimension X.'
Narrative Elements and Discrepancies
Narrative components within the season have been interpreted by some viewers as encouraging distrust of the presented events.
- Memory Sequences: Holly's progression through Vecna's memories requires the identification of inaccuracies, such as a merry-go-round depicted with an incorrect color.
- Visual Continuity: Other visual discrepancies mentioned include a tower pointer changing color from grey in Volume One to red in Volume Two.
- Character Dialogue: Will's speech references milkshakes at Melvald's, a detail that some interpret as inconsistent with the shop's current offerings. This has led to speculation that Vecna, in his past identity as Henry Creel, might remember Melvald's when it operated as a diner.
Meta-Commentary Speculation
Dialogue within the series has been interpreted by some fans as meta-commentary on the show's narrative structure and conclusion.
- Lucas's Statement: In season five, Volume One, Lucas states, 'I don’t believe in coincidences… not anymore,' while discussing Vecna’s plan. Some fan interpretations suggest this line serves as a subtle fourth-wall break, implying that specific narrative details are significant and that events may be more complex than they initially appear.
- Ending Frustration: Dialogue expressing dissatisfaction with overly tidy or perfect narrative conclusions, such as Max's frustration with Mike's Dungeons & Dragons endings, has also been interpreted by fans as the series subtly commenting on the nature of its own finale.