Back
Politics

Australian Government Halts Inland Rail Funding North of Parkes; Project Cost Exceeds $45 Billion

Generated on: Last updated: 4 sources
View source

Inland Rail Project Truncated: Federal Government Ceases Funding Beyond Parkes

The Australian federal government has ceased funding for the Melbourne-to-Brisbane Inland Rail project beyond the regional town of Parkes, New South Wales. The decision follows an independent assessment that estimated the full project cost at over $45 billion, more than three times the current budget allocation.

"The project was inherited as underfunded and under-planned." — Infrastructure Minister Catherine King

Construction will be completed between Beveridge, Victoria, and Parkes by the end of next year, enabling double-stacked freight trains to run between Melbourne and Perth via Parkes.

Cost and Timeline

Multiple independent reviews and government statements detail the project's cost escalation:

  • Current Estimate: An independent assessment by ACIL Allen estimated the full project cost at over $45 billion.
  • Previous Estimates: The project was initially allocated $8.4 billion in off-budget funding in 2017 by the Morrison government. Estimated costs have risen from $9.3 billion (2017) to $16.4 billion (2020).
  • 2023 Review: A 2023 independent review by Dr. Kerry Schott estimated the cost at $31.4 billion and questioned the reliability of that figure. Dr. Schott cited "immature preliminary designs" and prolonged approval processes as reasons for cost overruns.
  • Timeline: The ACIL Allen assessment indicated the earliest possible completion date for the full route is 2036. Dr. Schott's review had suggested a completion date of 2031.

Dr. Schott described the cost estimates as unreliable, pointing to "immature preliminary designs" and prolonged approval processes.

Funding and Scope

  • The government will reallocate $1.75 billion from the Inland Rail budget to complete the Beveridge-to-Parkes section.
  • An additional $55 million will be provided to incentivize shifting freight from road to rail or ships.
  • The original 1,700-kilometre route from Melbourne to a port near Brisbane has been truncated to approximately half that distance, ending at Parkes, New South Wales.
  • Minister King stated the project was inherited as "underfunded and under-planned" and that continued off-budget funding would require cutting other projects.

Governance Changes

  • Dr. Collette Burke has been appointed as the new chair of the Inland Rail board.
  • Dr. Sean Sweeney has been appointed as chief executive.
  • Minister King stated the appointments demonstrate "strong governance and clear accountability." Dr. Schott's 2023 review had criticized the board's skills.

Reactions Divided

Critics of the Decision

  • Business leaders, opposition politicians, and some regional mayors expressed disappointment, calling the decision short-sighted and damaging to regional economies and supply chain resilience.
  • Parkes Mayor Neil Westcott described the pause as "having an arm chopped off."
  • National Party leader Matt Canavan has launched a petition to revive the project.
  • Goondiwindi Mayor Lawrence Springborg criticized the project's management, contrasting it with historical rail construction speeds.

"We just want to know what's happening... the mixed messages and changing timeframes are really hard." — Katie Cox, landowner near Narromine

Supporters of the Decision

  • Local residents and the local federal MP in affected areas welcomed the decision, citing concerns over noise, environmental impact, and lack of community benefit.
  • Everald Compton, a retired corporate fundraiser who conceived the Inland Rail project, had previously stated the line would never reach Brisbane, calling the full route unrealistic.

Future Proposals

  • Private Sector: Minister King stated she will consider "unsolicited proposals" from the private sector. Everald Compton has proposed a private consortium to complete the project, arguing it could be built faster and cheaper with less political interference.
  • Party Positions: Barnaby Joyce (One Nation) stated the party will "100% back Inland Rail" if in government and expressed doubt regarding the $45 billion cost estimate.

Everald Compton, the project's original conceiver, has proposed a private consortium to complete the route, arguing it could be built "faster and cheaper with less political interference."

Background

  • The Inland Rail project was initially pledged with $300 million by both Labor and the Coalition in the 2013 federal election.
  • Funding was later provided by the Abbott government. In 2017, the Morrison government allocated $8.4 billion off-budget to the Australian Rail Track Corporation (ARTC).
  • The project was originally conceived by Everald Compton in 1998 with support from then-Prime Minister John Howard, with a vision for a line from Melbourne to Darwin. The route was formally set in 2010 to link Melbourne to Brisbane instead.
  • The project is managed by Inland Rail Pty Ltd, a subsidiary of ARTC.
  • The government did not provide figures on job losses resulting from the decision.