Back
Science

Study Links Higher Ultra-Processed Food Intake to Greater Thigh Muscle Fat Infiltration

Generated on: Last updated: 5 sources
View source

Study Links Ultra-Processed Foods to Muscle Fat in Adults at Risk for Knee Osteoarthritis

A study published in the journal Radiology has found an association between higher consumption of ultra-processed foods and increased fat infiltration within the thigh muscles of adults at risk for knee osteoarthritis. The research, which analyzed MRI scans and dietary data from 615 participants, observed this link regardless of total calorie intake. Experts note the study design shows correlation, not causation, and that further research is needed to understand the long-term implications and potential reversibility of the findings.

Study Overview and Methodology

The research analyzed data from participants in the Osteoarthritis Initiative (OAI), a long-term national study focused on knee osteoarthritis prevention and treatment. Participants were at risk for knee osteoarthritis but had no radiographic signs of the disease (grade 1 or lower on the Kellgren-Lawrence scale) and reported no joint pain or major comorbidities at the time of the MRI scans.

  • Participants: The study group consisted of 615 individuals with an average age of 60. The cohort included 340 women and 275 men, and 98% were non-Hispanic. The average body mass index (BMI) was 27.
  • Dietary Assessment: Researchers used validated food frequency questionnaires to assess dietary intake. Foods were classified using the NOVA system to estimate the percentage of daily calories derived from ultra-processed foods.
  • Muscle Analysis: Muscle quality was evaluated using axial MRI slices of the thighs. Fat infiltration within and between muscle fibers was graded from 0 to 4 using the Goutallier classification system. Two experienced readers independently scored 10 bilateral thigh muscles.
  • Statistical Models: The analysis used two primary regression models: one adjusted for body mass index (BMI) and another adjusted for abdominal circumference. Both models also accounted for factors including age, race, ethnicity, education, income, physical activity, total energy intake, depression, and smoking status.

Key Findings

After adjusting for BMI, higher intake of ultra-processed foods was significantly associated with greater fat infiltration in all thigh muscles.

  • Role of Fat Distribution: The associations were stronger in statistical models adjusted for abdominal circumference than in those adjusted for BMI alone.
  • Consistency: The relationship between ultra-processed food consumption and muscle fat infiltration was linear and consistent across both sexes.
  • Muscle Group Variation: Among the muscle groups analyzed, the adductors showed the strongest association with ultra-processed food intake. Flexor muscles exhibited the highest average fat infiltration, while extensor muscles showed the lowest.
  • Participant Data: On average, ultra-processed foods accounted for approximately 41% of the participants' daily energy intake, which averaged 1,381 kcal per day.

Context and Health Implications

Ultra-Processed Foods: These are industrial formulations typically high in salt, sugar, fat, and additives, and are designed for convenience and long shelf life. Examples include many packaged snacks, sugary drinks, reconstituted meat products, and pre-prepared meals.

Muscle Fat Infiltration: Intramuscular fat can interfere with muscle fiber regeneration and is associated with decreased muscle strength and quality.

Link to Knee Health: Weak thigh muscles are considered a known risk factor for the development and progression of knee osteoarthritis, a degenerative joint condition. Knee osteoarthritis affects nearly 375 million people worldwide.

Broader Health Predictor: Decreased muscle quality from fatty infiltration has been linked in other research to various negative health outcomes, including longer hospital stays and poorer surgical outcomes.

Researcher Statements

"Throughout the study, the more ultra-processed foods a person consumed, the more intramuscular fat they had in their thigh muscles, regardless of caloric intake." — Dr. Thomas Link, senior author of the study.

  • Dr. Zehra Akkaya, lead author of the study, stated that finding compromised muscle quality in individuals without signs of knee osteoarthritis was a notable observation.
  • Dr. Miriam Bredella, a radiologist not involved in the study, commented that fat infiltration appears to be a systemic process, suggesting other muscle groups in the body would likely show similar patterns. She noted the study showed "a strong association" but added, "We have no idea how long you have to eat ultra-processed food for this to happen to muscles. If you just stop eating those foods — would it go away?" Dr. Bredella also stated, "What we do know is that if you have fat infiltration of muscle and you start exercising and eating healthy, you can definitely improve your muscle quality."

General Recommendations Cited

Experts cited in the reports provided general recommendations for supporting muscle and joint health, which were not specific prescriptions from the study itself.

  • Exercise: Favoring low-impact activities over high-impact sports to reduce stress on knee joints. Suggested exercises included using elliptical trainers, strength training with weights, and targeted movements like wall squats, step-ups, and leg lifts.
  • Diet: Focusing on consuming whole, minimally processed foods prepared at home. Recommendations included reading product labels to choose less processed alternatives, adding whole grains and vegetables to the diet, replacing sugar-sweetened beverages with water, and selecting local restaurants over fast-food chains when eating out. Some experts cautioned that many commercial protein bars and supplements can be high in sugar.

Study Limitations and Future Research

  • Causality Not Established: The researchers emphasized that the cross-sectional design of the study means it can show an association but cannot prove that ultra-processed foods directly cause increased muscle fat infiltration.
  • Unanswered Questions: The study could not determine how long a person needs to consume ultra-processed foods for these muscle effects to occur, or whether stopping consumption would reverse existing fat infiltration.
  • Population Specificity: The findings are based on a specific population of older adults at risk for knee osteoarthritis, which may limit generalizability to other groups.
  • Next Steps: The authors noted that the findings support further research, including longitudinal studies, to clarify causal pathways and investigate whether dietary interventions can influence muscle quality and the progression of knee osteoarthritis.