Adam Simpson Defends Carlton Consultancy Amid Media Scrutiny

Former West Coast coach Adam Simpson has defended his consultancy role at the Carlton Football Club and explicitly denied any interest in coaching the Blues. Simpson addressed the criticism regarding his ability to balance his media commitments with his club duties during a recent appearance on AFL 360.

Criticism from Commentators

On Monday, Channel Seven commentators Caroline Wilson and Kane Cornes raised concerns about Simpson's part-time role at Princes Park.

Wilson questioned the effectiveness of a part-time mentor who also comments on the club. Cornes added that he had not observed significant success from part-timers in football and suggested Simpson's dual roles prevented him from performing optimally in either capacity.

Simpson's Clarification

Garry Lyon, co-host of AFL 360, presented the topic to Simpson, asking about potential links to a senior coaching position at Carlton.

Simpson clarified that his role is as a consultant, not a part-time position. He explained his responsibilities include working on development plans with assistant coaches and head coach Michael Voss. He stated his function is to provide an external perspective, offering observations and insights without being part of the internal "groupthink."

Simpson emphasized that when he accepted the role, he made it clear to his manager and Carlton CEO Graham Wright that he was not interested in coaching the club.

"If I ever wanted to coach Carlton, I wouldn't take this role. I'm here to try and support the current coach, not try and manipulate my way through."

He also commented on the notion that individuals cannot hold two roles, noting that other media personalities also work with football clubs.

Club Focus and Role Specifics

Simpson indicated he had not discussed the situation with Voss, asserting that the club's primary focus is on winning games, not external perceptions. He mentioned being criticized for his commentary on Carlton and acknowledged the need to balance his media obligations.

He provided an example of his consultancy work, detailing a conversation with Voss after a recent game where he offered insights into the team's second-half performance. He described his role as providing support and an external viewpoint, which is not part of the internal discussions regarding leadership.

Simpson concluded by labeling the suggestion that he took a supporting role to eventually become senior coach as "ridiculous" and "a little bit insulting."