Back
Sports

College Football Playoff Expansion to 24 Teams Debated as Officials and Networks Divide on Format

Generated on: Last updated: 5 sources
View source

College Football Playoff Expansion Debate Intensifies: 24 Teams or Bust?

The proposal to expand the College Football Playoff (CFP) from 12 teams to 24 teams by the 2027 season has garnered public support from several conference commissioners and network executives, while facing firm opposition from the Southeastern Conference (SEC) and its primary rights holder, ESPN. Unresolved issues include revenue projections, media rights negotiations, and the future of lucrative conference championship games.

Key Supporters and Opponents

Support for 24-Team Expansion

"Zero conversation about 16." — Big Ten Commissioner Tony Petitti, citing a "deep commitment to 24."

  • Big Ten Conference: Commissioner Tony Petitti publicly advocated for a 24-team format.
  • Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC): Commissioner Jim Phillips voiced support.
  • Big 12 Conference: Commissioner Brett Yormark backed the proposal.
  • Notre Dame: Athletic Director Pete Bevacqua expressed support.
  • Fox Sports: CEO Eric Shanks strongly favored a 24-team format. Sources indicate the network expressed interest in acquiring additional CFP broadcast rights.
  • Several Coaches and Athletic Directors: Georgia coach Kirby Smart, Tennessee coach Josh Heupel, Tennessee AD Danny White, Indiana AD Scott Dolson, and Maryland AD Jim Smith have all publicly supported expansion.

Opposition or Preference for Smaller Expansion

  • SEC: Commissioner Greg Sankey opposed expansion to 24 teams, stating a preference for a maximum of 16 teams.
  • ESPN: The current exclusive CFP rights holder—paying $1.3 billion annually through the 2031-32 season—indicated a preference to keep the playoff at 12 or 14 teams, no more than 16.

Financial and Revenue Considerations

Conference championship games collectively generate an estimated $200–250 million annually.

  • Elimination of Championship Games: A 24-team format would likely require eliminating conference championship games. The SEC's game alone is valued at approximately $100 million—a revenue source the SEC retains under the current structure.
  • Unconfirmed Projections: Media consultants have only recently begun modeling television revenue for a 24-team format. Optimistic projections have not yet been confirmed.
  • Economic Viability: Big Ten Commissioner Petitti stated that a 16-team format "does not work economically." UCLA Athletic Director Martin Jarmond noted that formal revenue models have not yet been presented to conferences.

Media Rights and Network Positions

  • ESPN: Sources at the network expressed concern that expanding to 24 teams could reduce viewership for high-stakes regular-season games. An ESPN source stated there is no historical evidence that larger playoff fields encourage schools to schedule tougher nonconference games.
  • Fox Sports: Lacking high-viewership regular-season games, Fox sees 24-team expansion as a means to improve its programming. CEO Eric Shanks expressed belief that a 24-team CFP could involve multiple networks.
  • TNT Sports: Already holds a sublicensing deal for CFP games. A potential merger with CBS could affect future bidding.
  • Media Analysis: Analyst John Kosner stated that additional media value from expansion might not meet expectations, as lower-ranked teams have less perceived chance of competing for a championship.

Decision-Making Authority

Under the current CFP contract, the Big Ten and SEC hold sole decision-making power over future postseason formats. If Petitti and Sankey disagree on the format, the playoff will remain at 12 teams. Final approval of any format change rests with university presidents.

Timeline for Decision

A decision on expansion is needed by a December 1 deadline, though commissioners expressed hope to reach an agreement by July. The next CFP Board of Managers meeting is scheduled for June.

Observations on Current 12-Team Format Performance

Top-Four Seed Quarterfinal Record

Over the first two seasons of the 12-team playoff, seven of eight teams that earned a first-round bye lost their subsequent quarterfinal game. Indiana, the top-seeded team in the current season, was the sole exception after defeating Alabama 38-3 in the Rose Bowl following an extended break.

Potential Format Adjustments

CFP officials may consider modifications to the playoff schedule, including:

  • Earlier Start: Moving the entire playoff schedule one week earlier to reduce the layoff for top seeds.
  • Expansion to 16 Teams: If adopted, discussions regarding the impact of extended breaks would continue.
  • Hosting Quarterfinal Games: Allowing top-seeded teams to host quarterfinal games on college campuses, contingent on addressing logistics related to winter commencement ceremonies and holidays.

CFP Executive Director Rich Clark stated that moving the playoff start date up by one week is "not off the table" and that commissioners and university presidents "will look at it and evaluate it as they do every year."

The 10 Football Bowl Subdivision commissioners and Notre Dame Athletic Director Pete Bevacqua are scheduled to meet in Miami later this month to address these issues.